Guide · Portfolio measurement governance

Private equity KPI standardization

By Derwin Lucas · · Revised

Private equity KPI standardization usually starts with systems or templates. It works when it starts with definitions: an agreed statement, for each KPI the sponsor relies on, of what counts, what it is divided by, which period it belongs to and what evidence supports it. Systems and templates can follow, or not.

A proposal to standardize definitions meets objections, from portfolio companies, from finance teams and sometimes from the sponsor itself. Most of them are reasonable, and each one, answered properly, adds something to what a standardized definition has to contain. This guide takes them in turn. All figures are illustrative.

01The objections

The objections, and what each one leaves out

Exhibit 1. The objections, and what each one leaves out

ObjectionWhat it gets rightWhat it leaves out
“Our numbers are already correct.”Each company’s figure is usually calculated correctlyCorrect figures on different definitions still don’t compare
“We already send every company the same template.”A template gives every company the same boxesEach company still decides what goes in them
“We have a KPI dictionary.”The definitions are written downWhether each company follows them, and where it doesn’t, is often unrecorded
“The dashboard already shows consistent KPIs.”Labels and charts are consistentThe inputs underneath may not be
“We’ll standardize once everyone is on one system.”A common system removes some differencesMigration is slow, and a common system can be configured differently by each company
“Our companies are too different.”Some work genuinely can’t be comparedA definition decides what is compared, not how a company runs
“Our companies won’t change how they report.”Companies need their own measures for their own managementThe portfolio figure can be restated from the company’s records, where they allow
“The definitions will change after the next acquisition.”They mayA definition with a version and an approval can change without breaking history
02Correct

“Our numbers are already correct”

They probably are. In one illustrative case, a company’s customer acquisition cost is $900 if it counts advertising alone and $1,200 if it counts the other acquisition costs the portfolio basis includes, and the customers it divides by may be counted at a signed contract at one company and at a completed job at another. Across 1,000 customers the cost difference is $300,000 per company, and at twelve companies, $3.6 million left out of the measure: not an additional cash loss, but a cost the figure doesn’t show. Where financing fees, installation labor and sales commissions are booked can put one P&L’s gross margin anywhere from 29.9% to 62.0%. Every one of those figures is calculated correctly. See the customer acquisition cost case

That is the objection’s strength and its limit. Correctness is a property of a calculation; comparability is a property of two calculations made the same way. A standard that fixes the label without fixing the calculation leaves every one of those figures in play, and a portfolio comparison will pick up whichever one each company happens to use.

What it adds to the definition: what counts, and what it is divided by.

03Tools

“We already have a template, a dictionary and a dashboard”

Each of these standardizes something real, and none of them standardizes the meaning of the number.

A common template gives every company the same boxes; each company still decides what goes in them, and which month it belongs to. Why a template doesn’t hold a definition A KPI dictionary writes the definitions down, but often nobody checks whether each company follows them, or records where it doesn’t. A shared dashboard shows consistent labels and charts over inputs that may not be consistent. How this differs from BI and portfolio monitoring

The gap in all three is the same: nothing connects the stated definition to the figure each company actually submits.

What it adds to the definition: the evidence that ties each figure to the definition, whether individual records or submitted totals with that limitation stated.

04One system

“We’ll standardize once everyone is on one system”

A system migration can remove real differences, and it may be worth doing for other reasons. As a route to comparable KPIs it has two problems. It is slow and expensive, and often unfinished when the board asks its question. And even a common system can be configured differently by each company: the same field, set up by different administrators, can record different events.

Definitions don’t need to wait. Each portfolio company can keep its own systems of record, and its data can arrive through connections, exports, extracts or monthly submissions, as long as the definition, not the system or the template, decides what goes in.

What it adds to the definition: the period each event belongs to.

05Too different

“Our companies are too different”

Sometimes they are. A restoration contractor’s loss-to-collection cycle and a remodeler’s installation backlog measure different work, and no definition makes them the same measure. But a portfolio definition decides what is compared, not how a company runs. Where companies do different kinds of work, define those KPIs trade by trade and compare within each group, and say plainly where a group has only one company in it. Home-services portfolio reporting across trades

What it adds to the definition: what is included and excluded. It states which companies, work types and records are in scope, and a total that covers 22 of 25 companies says so and names the three that are missing. See the reporting coverage case

06Reporting

“Our companies won’t change how they report”

They don’t have to. A company can keep its own definitions for its own management, and its leaders may be measured on them. The portfolio definition governs portfolio comparisons. Where a company’s records allow, its figure is restated under the portfolio definition; where they don’t, the figure is reported with the limitation stated. Record-level data can be recalculated. A per-customer cost submitted without its cost categories can’t be restated at all. Missing figures are stated as missing, never estimated.

This objection is worth hearing early, because it moves the work from persuading companies to reading their records.

What it adds to the definition: nothing new, but it settles who does the restating: the portfolio, from each company’s records.

07Change

“The definitions will change after the next acquisition”

They may. An add-on arrives with definitions of its own, and occasionally its way of counting is better than the portfolio’s. A definition that cannot change is as much a problem as one that changes silently.

The answer is to make each change a decision: a new version, approved, with an effective date, and earlier figures kept under the definition they were built on. An add-on is mapped to the current definitions before it is compared. Acquisition KPI integration Definition drift in portfolio reporting

What it adds to the definition: who approved it, and when.

The principle

Common systems are a project. Common definitions are a decision.

08The definition

KPI definitions across portfolio companies: what the answers add up to

Exhibit 2. A standardized KPI definition, using customer acquisition cost as the example

ElementThe question it answersFor customer acquisition cost: the choice to make
What countsWhich costs are counted?Advertising alone ($900 per customer in the illustrative case), or every acquisition cost the portfolio basis includes ($1,200)
What it is divided byPer what?Customers acquired: a signed contract or a completed job, stated once
The periodWhich month does it belong to?The month the cost is incurred, or the month the customer is acquired
ScopeWhich companies, work types and records are in?For example, every company in the portfolio, with any missing company named
EvidenceWhat must the figure rest on?Expense records by category, or submitted totals with that limitation stated
ApprovalWho decided, and since when?The CFO, with a version and an effective date

Each element came from an objection. A company’s figure can be compared without a stated caveat only when it meets all six. Where the evidence is weaker, it may still be compared with the limitation stated; where what counts or what it is divided by differs and can’t be restated, the figure is reported, not compared. In Goverisyn, every figure carries an evidence state (Substantiated, Qualified, Limited or Not Available), and whether it is compared is a separate ruling. What each state means

The order of work follows. Choose the few KPIs behind capital allocation, covenant compliance and valuation, not every metric anyone reports. Write all six elements of each definition, and have the CFO approve it, before asking any company to report against it. Record how each company calculates the KPI today and exactly where that differs. Restate where the records allow. From then on, change a definition only by a recorded decision with an effective date.

09Where to start

Start with one KPI and its objections

Pick one KPI the sponsor already uses to make a decision, write its full definition, and put it in front of the companies before collecting another month of it. The objections that come back will tell you which of the six elements each company is missing.

Goverisyn’s Portfolio Measurement Review does this across selected brands, after a free 45-minute Portfolio Review that needs no data in advance. For how to apply the definitions once they exist, see How to compare performance across acquired companies and EBITDA comparability across portfolio companies.

Start with a Portfolio Review.

45 minutes. No data needed in advance.

By Derwin Lucas, founder of Goverisyn, with a career in management and information systems in home services. Published . Revised . About Goverisyn