EBITDA comparability across portfolio companies
By Derwin Lucas · · Revised
EBITDA comparability across portfolio companies means every brand’s EBITDA is stated on the same basis: the same treatment of shared-service costs, the same recognition of rebates, and the same rules for adjustments. Not every divergence between brands moves EBITDA, however. Several move only the margins above it, which is where brands are most often compared and ranked.
Knowing which figure a divergence moves is the first step in deciding what to standardize. All figures are illustrative.
Where each divergence lands
Exhibit 1. Where each divergence lands (illustrative)
| Divergence between brands | Gross or job margin | Brand EBITDA | Adjusted EBITDA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shared-service costs carried by some brands and not others | No change | Moves: $1,500,000 before a $150,000 allocation, $1,350,000 after | Moves with it |
| Commissions and installation labor booked above or below gross margin | Moves: one P&L’s margin can read anywhere from 29.9% to 62.0% | No change, if the costs are booked somewhere | No change |
| Financing dealer fees left out of contribution margin | Moves: $10,000,000 of financed sales at 2.5% is $250,000 per brand | No change, if the fees are booked somewhere | No change |
| Callback and warranty costs kept out of job costs | Moves: 500 jobs at $400 is $200,000 per brand | No change, if the costs are booked somewhere | No change |
| Vendor rebates counted when negotiated rather than when earned, accrued or received | Depends on where they are booked | Moves: in timing, and in amount if the negotiated maximum is never fully earned | Moves: in timing, and in amount if the negotiated maximum is never fully earned |
| Recurring costs presented as one-time adjustments | No change | No change | Moves: $600,000 at 8.0× puts $4.8 million of implied enterprise value at issue |
Read down the columns and three different problems appear, each with a different owner.
Margins: a classification problem
Half the divergences in the exhibit sit in the first column. Where a brand books these costs changes its gross, contribution or job margin without changing its EBITDA at all. Commissions, installation labor and financing fees alone can put one P&L’s gross margin anywhere from 29.9% to 62.0%, so two brands with identical EBITDA can report gross margins more than thirty points apart.
That matters because margins, not EBITDA, are what operating reviews usually compare. A margin ranking built on different classifications ranks bookkeeping. The remedy is a portfolio chart of accounts that places each contested cost in one line for every brand, and a restatement of each brand’s margin onto it where its P&L shows the costs separately. See the margin arithmetic
Brand EBITDA: an allocation and timing problem
Two divergences move brand EBITDA itself.
The first is shared-service cost. A brand that does not carry its share reports EBITDA above what it would on the portfolio basis: $1,500,000 rather than $1,350,000 in the illustrative case, 10% lower once allocated, with nothing changed in the business. Portfolio EBITDA does not move; the comparison between brands does. In an illustrative 25-brand portfolio, eight brands that each leave out about $150,000 report $1.2 million more brand EBITDA between them than they would on the portfolio’s basis. See the overhead allocation case
The second is rebate timing. A rebate counted when it is negotiated lands in an earlier period than one counted when it is earned, accrued or received. A negotiated maximum may also never be fully earned. Either way, two brands with the same purchasing can report different EBITDA.
Both are settled by a written basis: one allocation method applied to every brand, and one recognition point for rebates. How to make brand EBITDA comparable
Exhibit 2. One brand, from reported to portfolio basis
Illustrative: three cases from this guide applied to one brand.
| Line | Amount | Effect on EBITDA |
|---|---|---|
| Brand EBITDA as reported | $1,500,000 | – |
| Shared-service allocation on the portfolio basis | −$150,000 | Lowers it |
| Financing dealer fees moved into contribution margin | – | None; contribution margin falls by $250,000 |
| Callback and warranty costs moved into job costs | – | None; job margin falls by $200,000 |
| Brand EBITDA on the portfolio basis | $1,350,000 | 10% lower than reported |
The bridge does two things a single restated figure cannot. It shows the brand’s team exactly which decisions changed its number, so the restatement reads as a basis applied to everyone rather than a judgment about one brand. And it keeps the reported figure in view. Brand leaders are often paid and managed on their own figures; the portfolio basis is for comparison, and it is clearer to publish both, side by side, than to replace one with the other. The two middle lines also show why a brand’s margin can fall while its EBITDA holds: reclassification moves costs between lines, not out of the P&L.
Adjusted EBITDA: which add-backs qualify
The last row is the one valuation multiplies. A recurring cost presented as one-time does not change reported EBITDA; it changes the adjusted figure used at exit, in a covenant test or in a lender’s model. At an illustrative 8.0× multiple, $600,000 of recurring costs presented as adjustments puts $4.8 million of implied enterprise value at issue. The question is not the arithmetic but whether those costs qualify as adjustments at all.
A recurring cost added back also flatters the trend: it returns the following year, and the apparent improvement reverses. Reviewing adjusted EBITDA add-backs against documented criteria as brands report, rather than once at a transaction, means each add-back’s classification and evidence are already on record when a buyer’s quality-of-earnings team tests the figure. How adjustments are reviewed between deals
Brand EBITDA comparability depends on definitions as well as operating results.
Setting one basis
The three problems share a remedy, applied in a different place each time. A portfolio basis states, once and in writing, how shared costs are allocated, where each contested cost is classified, when rebates are recognized and what qualifies as an adjustment. Each brand’s figures are restated onto that basis where its records allow. Where they do not, as when a brand reports cost of goods as a single figure, the brand’s figure is reported with that limitation stated rather than adjusted by estimate. Each figure keeps its method, the brands and period it covers, and the source amounts behind it, so it can answer a lender’s or a board’s question about where it came from.
The basis is a finance decision. The CFO should approve it, FP&A should apply it, and brand controllers should record where their practice departs from it. Each version carries an effective date, so a change agreed in March cannot quietly restate January. Goverisyn doesn’t set the basis; your leadership does.
In Goverisyn, every figure carries an evidence state: Substantiated, Qualified, Limited or Not Available. What each state means
Start with shared costs
Shared-cost allocation is the divergence that touches every brand and moves EBITDA itself, and its method needs to be agreed only once. Agree it, apply it to every brand, and compare each brand’s EBITDA before and after. Then take classification and adjustments in turn.
Goverisyn’s Portfolio Measurement Review tests a portfolio basis across selected brands, after a free 45-minute Portfolio Review that needs no data in advance. For the same approach applied to operating KPIs, see How to compare performance across acquired companies.
More guides on financials
EBITDA growth since acquisition: separating performance from changes in basis
Adjusted EBITDA diligence questions for home-services roll-ups
EBITDA add-backs: which ones hold up, and the record that shows it
Covenant EBITDA vs adjusted EBITDA: what the credit agreement counts
Sell-side quality of earnings: what to have on record before the review begins
Start with a Portfolio Review.
45 minutes. No data needed in advance.
By Derwin Lucas, founder of Goverisyn, with a career in management and information systems in home services. Published . Revised . About Goverisyn