Home-services portfolio reporting across trades
By Derwin Lucas · · Revised
Home-services portfolio reporting gets harder when a private-equity-backed platform owns brands in more than one trade. An HVAC company, a roofer, a restoration contractor and a bath remodeler all report a close rate, a sale and a margin, but the work behind those words follows different paths. Some measures can be compared across trades once they share a basis. Others only mean something within a single trade.
The difference can be set out in two tables: one showing where each trade’s work becomes a sale, and one showing which measures can travel between trades and which cannot. This guide builds both, then reads multi-trade reporting off them. All figures are illustrative.
Four trades, four paths to a sale
Exhibit 1. Four trades, four paths to a sale
| Trade | Path of the work | Points that may count as the sale |
|---|---|---|
| HVAC, plumbing and electrical | Booked call, dispatch, completed service call, estimate, replacement opportunity, sold work, installed revenue | A completed service call, a sold replacement or a membership: three sales, each with its own population |
| Roofing and exteriors | Inspection, claim, contingency, supplement, contract, production milestones, completion | For insurance work, the claim, the contingency or the final contract; for retail work, the contract |
| Restoration | Loss, emergency response, mitigation, authorization, insurance approval, remediation, reconstruction, collection | Authorization, or insurance approval |
| Bath and home remodeling | Lead, appointment set, confirmed, issued to a rep, demonstration, contract, rescission, financing, retention, production, completion | The signed contract, the end of the rescission period, financing approval, or the job reaching production |
Every row ends in something a brand would call a sale, and no two rows mean the same thing by it. The same label sits at a different point in each trade’s sequence, and in every trade above at more than one point. See the trades side by side
One label, several sales
The choice of sale point changes the number even within one brand. In one illustrative brand’s month, the same records produce close rates of 33%, 27%, 20% and 13%, depending on what counts as the sale and what it is divided by. That is a definitional problem, and it can be solved within a trade by agreeing one sale point and one denominator. See the four close rates
Across trades, the problem goes further. A remodeler’s demonstration close rate and an HVAC company’s replacement close rate do not measure the same event at different points; they measure different events altogether. No agreement on definitions can make them the same measure, because the work underneath them is not the same work. Why KPIs differ between brands
Trades also divide internally. Retail and insurance roofing jobs take different routes, and windows, doors and siding have sales and installation cycles of their own. Water, fire and mold losses can each move differently through restoration. An HVAC company’s service, replacement and membership work are three populations, not one.
Which measures travel
Exhibit 2. Which measures travel
| Measure | Across trades | Within a trade |
|---|---|---|
| Gross margin and brand EBITDA | Yes, once every brand books costs the same way and carries its share of shared-service costs. Without that basis, one P&L’s gross margin can read anywhere from 29.9% to 62.0% | Yes, on the same basis |
| Receivables and cash | Yes, when aged from the same event in every trade, such as completion | Yes |
| Reporting coverage | Yes: which brands and trades sit inside each total. A total covering 22 of 25 brands should name the missing brands, and so the trades they belong to | Yes |
| Revenue | Its level shows size, not performance | Its level shows size, not performance |
| Close rate | No. The sale is a different event in each trade | Yes, once the sale point and denominator are agreed |
| Average contract value | No. Pooled across trades, it describes the mix of trades | Yes, among brands doing the same kind of work |
| Trade-specific operating measures | No | Yes: rescission, financing approval and installation backlog in remodeling; dispatch-to-completion and membership renewals in HVAC; claim, contingency and supplement outcomes in insurance roofing; loss-to-collection cycle time in restoration |
Reading the matrix
Broadly, the line falls between financial results stated on one basis and measures of the work itself. Financial results stated on one portfolio basis can be compared across trades, because a dollar of margin or a day of receivables means the same thing in every trade once the accounting is agreed. Comparable is not the same as like-for-like: a margin gap between trades reflects the trades’ economics as well as either brand’s performance. Measures of the work itself describe the work, and the work differs. Average contract value is the instructive exception: it is in dollars, but it measures the size of a job, and jobs differ by trade. EBITDA comparability across portfolio companies
That gives multi-trade portfolio reporting, and the PE-backed home-services analytics built on it, a simple shape. Financial measures are reported across the portfolio on one basis. Operating measures are reported within trade groups, and within a trade, among brands doing the same kind of work. Every figure states its population: which brands, trades and periods it covers. See the reporting coverage case
Three mistakes the matrix rules out
Each of the following uses a measure in the wrong column.
- Comparing close rates across trades. Ranking a remodeler’s demonstration close rate against an HVAC company’s replacement close rate tells you neither which business sells better nor which needs attention.
- Pooling contract values across trades. A portfolio average ticket that mixes restoration jobs, roof replacements and service calls moves when the mix of trades moves, whatever happens to performance in each of them.
- Reading revenue levels as performance. Revenue shows how large each brand is. A brand in a high-ticket trade can lead a revenue table whether or not it is performing well.
A fourth mistake is structural: sending every brand the same reporting template. One template for every trade either leaves out the stages that matter to some trades or forces brands to fill boxes that don’t fit their work. Why a template doesn’t hold a definition
A close rate is a trade’s measure. Margin is the portfolio’s.
Building the groups
Operating comparisons need groups, and groups need a record of what each brand does. Classify every brand by trade and by the kinds of work it does. A roofer that also installs windows and siding, or that does both retail and insurance work, belongs in more than one group. Where its records separate the lines of work, report them separately; where they don’t, report the combined figure with that limitation stated.
Then define each trade’s measures for that trade. For each one, agree what counts as the sale and what it is divided by, and apply the definition to every brand in the trade. A definition that suits remodeling won’t suit restoration, and it shouldn’t have to. The portfolio-wide financial basis is agreed once, for every brand in every trade.
Some groups will be small. A trade with one brand in it has nothing to be compared with, and that is worth saying plainly rather than filling the gap with a comparison across trades. In a portfolio, a comparison that cannot be made is better reported as such than replaced by one that can be made but means little.
Start with the list of brands
List every brand with its trade and its kinds of work, then pick one financial measure to put on a single basis. The list alone shows which comparisons the platform can make today and which it can’t.
Goverisyn’s Portfolio Measurement Review does this across selected brands, after a free 45-minute Portfolio Review that needs no data in advance. For comparisons within a trade, see How to compare performance across acquired companies.
More guides on comparing brands
Start with a Portfolio Review.
45 minutes. No data needed in advance.
By Derwin Lucas, founder of Goverisyn, with a career in management and information systems in home services. Published . Revised . About Goverisyn